30+ Years On, Stanley Kubrick’s Masterpiece The Shining Still Mesmerizes
Posted by c taylor
Struggling to turn his life around in the wake of alcoholism and the abuse of his child, writer Jack Torrance (Jack Nicholson) agrees to take a 5 month long off-season caretaker position at The Overlook Hotel. Completely isolated and left to his own devices, Jack’s young son, Danny (Danny Lloyd), begins seeing things thanks to a unique psychic gift referred to as “shining”. As a snowstorm moves in, completely cutting off the Torrance family from the rest of the world, Danny is plagued with visions of the future, events from the past, and is visited by ghosts who inhabit the hotel.
Also starring Shelley Duvall as Wendy Torrance, Jack’s wife and Danny’s mother, and Scatman Crothers as Dick Hallorann, the hotel’s chef and a man who shares Danny’s gift, The Shining is directed by Stanley Kubrick and is (loosely, very loosely) based on a novel of the same name by Stephen King.
The division echoed by the film reviewing community and filmgoers alike when mention of Kubrick’s The Shining is made constitutes an all too familiar sentiment when the work of a popular author (Stephen King) is adapted to film. Kubrick’s 144 minute adaptation is a slow-paced, dream-state that often breaks with the underlying themes, subject matter, and overall tone of King’s novel. In fact, King has been quoted as saying Kubrick’s vision of his work is the only adaptation he could “remember hating” mainly due to Kubrick’s changes to the personality of the main character, Jack.
There is a litany of theories in print and online that would like to inject deeper (and potentially more sinister) meaning into Kubrick’s intentional variances to King’s original work; including one that would have you believe Kubrick’s The Shining is the director’s confession to having been a part to the staging of the Apollo 11 lunar landing (see below for a link to the full-length documentary). Still others, would ask that you consider Kubrick’s lifelong obsession with the Holocaust, and his frustration at never having been able to find an adequate project in which the matter could be explored, as a reason for the director’s hijacking of the film’s subject matter. 
Most of these theories are laughable, but strangely entertaining to investigate. I, myself, lost many hours in a YouTube rabbit hole delving into such theories. I invite you to do the same. All of it, even the crackpot ideas, lend themselves to the Kubrick mythology and are relentlessly fascinating. The documentary, Room 237, gives itself over to the investigation of such theories and we encourage you to take a look.
However you take Kubrick’s adaptation, a few irrefutable truths remain. Kubrick’s The Shining is a multi-layered experience, replete with recurring motifs (Kubrick relies heavily on mirrors throughout the film), and shot construction as a method of revealing or concealing the true nature of the events taking place in the scene.
Is Kubrick’s The Shining a ghost story? Not necessarily. As film critic Roger Ebert pointed out, Kubrick’s The Shining lacks a reliable character from whose viewpoint the audience can be informed. It’s never exactly clear whether the ghosts depicted in the film actually “exist” or are just mental manifestations of Jack or Danny, both of whom have questionable mental health.
This means, we are never given a context for understanding the motivations or the intent of the ghosts inhabiting The Overlook Hotel. Nor can we trust that the ghosts actually “exist.”
Kubrick’s The Shining then becomes a story about choice, not of ghosts, predetermination, or reincarnation (don’t let the photo at the end of the film fool you). All of the characters in the film have multiple roles. For instance, Jack is a father and husband. He is both good and evil. He is simultaneously an abusive and caring father and husband. It is up to Jack to choose which he wishes to be.
In a sense, then, this means Kubrick’s The Shining should be viewed through the lens of being a psychological horror film despite it’s supernatural elements.
And that’s not a bad place to be, especially considering the most powerful moments in the film center around the mental fracturing, or unraveling, of its central characters, not the ghosts of The Overlook Hotel. Even while the scene in which the room 237 “hag” chooses to reveal her true self to Jack is disturbing, it holds but a candle to the sense of “off-ness” you will feel when Jack is shown standing, staring out the window (see above photo).
Drenched in natural light, unshaven, with pink irritated eyes, everything about this single moment in Kubrick’s The Shining tells the audience things have just gone irrevocably off the rails.
Despite the inconsistencies between book and film, of which there are many, Kubrick’s The Shining remains one of my favorite films. It’s difficult to admit, given the fragile, hysteria-prone depiction of Wendy who continually allows herself to be mentally and verbally abused by her husband, Jack.
The decadence of the Gold Room, the never ending hallways, and grand interior design of the hotel lend a visual opulence to the film that I find intoxicating. Every viewing of The Shining reveals something new. Arguably, Kubrick’s masterpiece.
Okay that’s enough Gif’s for now.
 ”The Shining (film)” Wikipedia: The Free Encyclopedia. Wikimedia Foundation, Inc. 15 Feb. 2013. Web. 17 Feb. 2013. <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_shining_film>
- Cinefantastique (sgtr.wordpress.com)
- Wayne Rogers Counters Todd Keisling’s Abuse of ‘The Shining’ With a… Shining Review! (horrornovelreviews.com)
- “The Shining” (1980) (littlehouseofgiallo.wordpress.com)
- Kubrick (behance.net)
- The Shining and The Steadicam (tested.com)
About c taylorA Pacific Northwest native, C. Taylor is a former information technology professional whose development experience in the digital realm fueled a passion to explore and write about the world around us. She is a contributing scribe for several online entertainment publications including Mediocrity is the New Genius and Next Projection. In addition, she is a staff writer and producer for MITNG TV webseries. Her short fiction work has appeared in the 2005 and 2006 editions of ULE. She is an active member of the Pacific Northwest Writers Association. You can catch up with her on Twitter: @ctaylor
Posted on October 17, 2013, in FILM and tagged 30 / 30, Behind the scenes, clips from The Shining, Crypto-Kubrology, Danny Lloyd, Director Stanley Kubrick, Does The Overlook Hotel exist?, Entertainment, Film, films based on a book, hidden messages in The Shining, horror, Jack, Jack Nicholson, Jack Torrance, jacknicholson, Movie, movies based on a book, psychological horror, Room 237, Scatman Crothers, Shelley Duvall, Shining, Stanley Kubrick, Stanley Kubrick's The Shining (1980), Stephen King, Stephen King's The Shining, The Shining, The Shining ax scene, The Shining Code, Top 50 Scariest Movies of All Time, what is The Shining code?. Bookmark the permalink. Leave a Comment.